Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board

Students in moot court

Who We Are

The Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board is a student-run, honorary organization that focuses on recruiting and training the finest oral and written advocates in the country and is the oldest, largest, and most prestigious advocacy program at the University of Miami School of Law. The Moot Court Board was founded in 1953. Named in 2006 for the fifty-five-year member of the Florida Bar, former member of the Florida Legislature, and true “lawyer’s lawyer,” the Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board is committed to fostering and honing those qualities that its namesake represents: skill, passion, and excellence in advocacy. With the support of the University of Miami School of Law as well as local and national alumni, the Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board hopes to impart those skills on its current and future members.

John T. Gaubatz Moot Court Competition
The Gaubatz competition is the main moot court contest at Miami Law used to select the top twenty-five advocates for the Charles C. Papy Moot Court Board based on performance. Competitors argue their respective positions in front of three very distinguished judges. (More information below in "How to Join.")

Read All Papy Moot Court News

 

 2021-22 Moot Court Executive Board

Taylor Hill
President
tah39@law.miami.edu 

 

Tori Simkovic
Executive Vice-President
txs838@law.miami.edu

 

Lauren Palen
Vice-President, Inter-school
lnp34@law.miami.edu

 

Anoosheh Shaikh
Vice-President, Gaubatz Competition
axs724@law.miami.edu

 

Sabrina Janeiro 
Vice-President, Alumni & Public Relations
saj67@law.miami.edu

 

Jonathan Gutierrez
Vice-President, Appellate Advocacy I
jag652@law.miami.edu

 

Jose Lopez-Varela
Vice-President, Appellate Advocacy II
jlopezvarela@law.miami.edu

 

Ivan Smerznak
Vice-President, CKP Competition
ids31@law.miami.edu

 

 2021-22 Moot Court Board Members

Harris Blum

Sarah Coleman

Alexa Garcia

Jonathan Gutierrez

Madison Hauser

Taylor Hill

Sabrina Janeiro

John "Jack" Keller

Elanny Lago

Taylor Larson

Leandra Lopez

Amanda Lopez-Cardet

Jose Lopez-Varela

Helena Masiello

Max Matiauda

Lauren Palen

Ashley Parsons

Alex Picard 

Sam Sachs

Logan Sandler

Anoosheh Shaikh 

Tori Simkovic

Ivan Smerznak

Kevin Stone

Harrell Watts

 

What We Do

Each year, the Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board sends its members across the nation to compete against top law schools in a variety of competitions. This past year, members competed in competitions against dozens of law schools across the nation.

 National Appellate Advocacy Competition

The National Appellate Advocacy Competition (NAAC) is hosted by the American Bar Association’s Law Student Division each year. The ABA hosts six regional competitions across the nation, culminating in a national completion in Chicago in which the top four teams from each region compete. This year, the problem centered on Title IX and judicial deference to administrative agencies. The University of Miami School of law was represented by two teams of three students—two oral advocates and one brief writer—at the Brooklyn regional competition. Each team advanced to the one of four regional finals rounds. Both teams were also recognized for their written briefs: one team earning best brief for the region and the other earning fifth best brief.

 Duberstein Bankruptcy Moot Court Competition

The Duberstein Bankruptcy Moot Court Competition is hosted by the St. John’s School of Law in conjunction with the American Bankruptcy Institute. The competition is the largest, single-site appellate moot court competition, drawing approximately sixty law school teams to New York City each year. This year, the Papy Moot Court Board sent two teams of three students—two oral advocates and one brief writer—to the competition in Brooklyn. One team advanced to the final rounds while the other advanced to the semi-finals. Also, one team’s brief was recognized with an honorable mention.

 Evan A. Evans Constitutional Law Moot Court Competition

The Evan A. Evans Constitutional Law Moot Court Competition is hosted by the University of Wisconsin Law School. The 2016–2017 competition problem focused on the Fourth and Fifth Amendment implications of shared living spaces and smartphone technology. University of Miami’s two-student team advanced to the octo-final round and was honored with an award for second-best Petitioner brief.

 Iriving R. Kaufman Memorial Securities Law Moot Court Competition

The Irving R. Kaufman Memorial Securities Law Moot Court Competition takes place each year at Fordham University’s School of Law. Throughout the years, the Kaufman Competition has hosted several distinguished final-round judges, including Justice Samuel Alito, Justice Antonin Scalia, Justice Byron White, appellate judges, and commissioners of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission. In 2016, the University of Miami moot court team won the competition, besting thirty-one other teams and earning the change to argue before Justice Alito.

 John J. Gibbons Criminal Procedure Moot Court Competition

The John J. Gibbons Criminal Procedure Moot Court Competition is hosted each March by the Seton Hall University School of Law. In 2014, the University of Miami moot court team, coached by Howard Srebnick, took first in the competition. This year, the University of Miami took home third-best brief and a best oralist award.

 Civil Rights and Liberties Moot Court Competition

The Civil Rights and Liberties Moot Court Competition is organized and run by Emory Law Moot Court Society in the Fall semester of each year. The competition rounds are judged by practitioners from the Atlanta community with a final round decided by federal judges and state supreme court justices.

 Robert Orseck Memorial Moot Court Competition

The Robert Orseck Memorial Moot Court Competition is hosted by The Young Lawyers Division of The Florida Bar as a part of the Florida Bar Annual Convention in Boca Raton, Florida. Each year, the competition offers students the opportunity to tackle interesting and challenging issues in Florida and federal constitutional law. And because it is open only to law schools in the State of Florida, the Orseck Competition makes for an exciting bit of rivalry and comradery.

 National Moot Court Competition

The New York City Bar hosts the National Moot Court Competition (NMCC), with regional competitions each November and final rounds each February. As one of the oldest moot court competitions in the county, the NMCC attracts teams from over 120 law schools throughout the United States.

 Burton D. Wechsler First Amendment Moot Court Competition

The Burton D. Wechsler First Amendment Moot Court Competition is held annually at American University Washington College of Law in Washington, D.C. Now in its 24th year, the competition routinely draws federal appellate and district court judges as well as First Amendment scholars to judge competitors on their brief-writing and oral advocacy skills.

 Jerome Prince Memorial Evidence Competition

The Jerome Prince Memorial Evidence Competition has been hosted by the Brooklyn Law School since 1985. The appellate moot court competition challenges students to engage in contemporary issues in evidence law.

 E. Earle Zehmer National Moot Court Competition

The E. Earle Zehmer National Moot Court Competition is hosted by the Workers’ Compensation Institute as a part of its annual conference. Unique among moot court competitions, the Zehmer Competition focuses exclusively on workers’ compensation law. As a result, the competition rounds are scored by practitioners, commissioners, and judges with experience in that practice area. In 2015, the University of Miami moot court team became the champions of the competition, taking first place and earning best brief.

 Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition (NELMCC)

The Jeffrey G. Miller National Environmental Law Moot Court Competition (NELMCC) is hosted every year by Pace University, The Elizabeth Haub School of Law. NELMCC uses issues drawn from real cases to provide students first-hand experience in environmental litigation while also providing a rigorous academic experience. The Competition is distinctive in that three adverse teams argue the issues, reflecting the fact that environmental litigation frequently involves multiple parties — the government, a public interest group, and a member of the regulated industry. The University of Miami Moot Court team are the current champions of the competition.

 Cardozo BMI Entertainment and Media Law Moot Court Competition

The Cardozo BMI Entertainment and Media Law Moot Court Competition is hosted by the Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law Moot Court Honor Society. In 1987, marked the beginning of BMI’s (Broadcast Music, Inc.) involvement and co-sponsorship of the competition. Since these early beginnings, the competition has grown to 30 teams. In addition, the competition has drawn top judges and lawyers to offer their insight to the competitors.

How to Join

Application to the Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board is open to second- and third-year students of the University of Miami School of Law who have demonstrated excellence in written and oral advocacy. Each fall semester, the Board hosts the John T. Gaubatz Competition to determine the incoming class of moot court board candidates. Participation in the Gaubatz Competition is open to those University of Miami School of Law students who have achieved a cumulative GPA of 2.8 or higher for second-year (2Ls) students or 3.0 or higher for third-year students (3Ls) by the registration deadline. Membership is then extended to the top 25 second-year law students as well as to those third-year law students who rank in the top 25 competitors overall.

The Gaubatz Competition is comprised of both a written and an oral component. Competitors register in pairs, file an appellate brief, and argue in at least two oral rounds. The top sixteen, two-person teams go on to compete in a single-elimination, bracketed competition, which culminates in a final, evening round that is open to all competitors, students, professors, alumni, and the general public.

 2021 John T. Gaubatz Moot Court Compettion

The Gaubatz Competition will be held on October 16-19, 2021 at the law school. Registration is currently open. For more information, check the Competition TWEN page. If you have any questions about the Gaubatz Competition, you can contact Gaubatz Vice President, Anoosheh Shaikh, at gaubatzmootcourtcompetition@law.miami.edu, or Moot Court Director, Farah Barquero, at fbarquero@law.miami.edu.

 

Other Ways to Get Involved

If you would like to volunteer to judge practice rounds, help prepare us for our national competitions, or otherwise support the Charles C. Papy, Jr. Moot Court Board, email us at MootCourtBoard@law.miami.edu. And be sure to join our Facebook page and follow us on TwitterInstagram, and LinkedIn!

 

CONTACT INFORMATION

Senior Coordinator, Student Organizations - Merissa Williams
E-mailmerissawilliams@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-8542
Location: D334

Dean of Students - Janet Stearns
E-mail: jstearns@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-4551
Location: A212 (2nd floor behind the fountain)

Assistant Dean of Students - Amy Perez
E-mail: aperez@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-1880
Location: A211a

Assistant Director of Student LifeOdetta Clarke
E-mail: oclarke@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-3270
Location: F309b

Assistant Director of Student Life - Jack Townsend
E-mail: jack.townsend@law.miami.edu
Location: F209b

QUICKLINKS
Student Resources
Events Calendar
Student E-mail
CaneLink Student Portal
Registrar
Financial Aid

 

CONTACT INFORMATION

Senior Coordinator, Student Organizations - Merissa Williams
E-mailmerissawilliams@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-8542
Location: D334

Dean of Students - Janet Stearns
E-mail: jstearns@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-4551
Location: A212 (2nd floor behind the fountain)

Assistant Dean of Students - Amy Perez
E-mail: aperez@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-1880
Location: A211a

Assistant Director of Student LifeOdetta Clarke
E-mail: oclarke@law.miami.edu
Phone: 305-284-3270
Location: F309b

Assistant Director of Student Life - Jack Townsend
E-mail: jack.townsend@law.miami.edu
Location: F209b

QUICKLINKS
Student Resources
Events Calendar
Student E-mail
CaneLink Student Portal
Registrar
Financial Aid