Jewish law begins with the immutable and unchangeable laws found in what is called the Written Law (the Torah) and its companion law, the Oral Law (or Oral Torah). Flowing from these sources is an entire system of law that was developed over centuries by rabbis from around the world. The substance of Jewish law is found, not in any official government pronouncement, but rather in the intellectual product of rabbis of the past 2000 years. The authoritativeness of a legal work has been determined, not by force of arms or sovereign government, but rather by the work's acceptance by the Jewish people over a period of time. In other words, Jewish law is found in the rabbinical works that history has accorded the force of law. These works, and the laws contained within them, flow from rabbinical interpretation of the Written Law and the Oral Law. These rabbinical works take many forms, but can be grouped in the following general categories: the direct commentary on the Oral Law called the Gemara; commentary on the Gemara; legal codes compiled from the laws in the Torah, Oral Law and Gemara; and case law decisions applying these laws (called responsa). In sum, the corpus of primary sources of Jewish law is made up of the Written Law, the Oral Law, and associated authoritative intellectual product of rabbis.
Much of this material addresses the particulars of Jewish religions observance and the ancient Temple rites. However a component of Jewish law deals with matters that are today thought of as civil law and criminal matters: business relationships, evidence, torts, property, theft etc. It is this component, called by many modern scholars of Jewish law, mishpat ivri, which will probably be the primary focus of most Jewish legal research and scholarship conducted in the context of a secular law school library. While this research guide does not exclude information about the religious and ritual laws, it will offer more detailed information about researching the mishpat ivri component of Jewish law.
The following research guide is broken up into two main sections. The first section explains how the researcher who is not well-versed in Jewish law can use secondary resources written by contemporary scholars as a tool to conduct Jewish law research. In the second section, the content, historical development, and authority of each of the major authoritative primary sources of Jewish law is explained. Included in this section are research strategy tips offering practical advice on how to use these sources. These sections are contained in a gray "research strategy box."
Secondary Sources of Jewish Law: Contemporary Treatises
Research in Jewish law (halakhah - Heb.) is extremely complicated and will be difficult for the non-expert. None of the primary sources are in English, and although a most have been translated, not all of them have. Primary sources of Jewish law can date back over two thousand years and are not integrated and organized in a comprehensive and integrated system of authority as is the American legal system. Complicating matters further is the lack of a clear distinction between primary sources and normally would be considered a secondary source. For example, a rabbi's commentary on the Torah may have such authority that the commentary itself functions as a primary source of law. For purposes of this research guide legal works that function as an actual source of the law itself, even though by definition may be a secondary source of law, will be treated as a primary source of Jewish law. Another obstacle to the non-expert is the lack of a comprehensive finding tool for Jewish law (such as a digest system or searchable database).
Because the uninitiated researcher will face many obstacles in the use of primary sources, contemporary treatises, are probably the most important research tool for the non-expert. Contemporary treatises of Jewish law form a body of literature written by contemporary scholars and rabbis about topics of Jewish law. These are written, for the most part, by scholars who are able to access the original sources in their original languages and these authors will almost invariably cite to those sources. These helpful resources may be multivolume sets, single monographs or law journal articles. Most law school libraries are likely to be far better stocked in these secondary sources than in the original sources discussed in the second section of this guide. These may be used to both learn about the substance of Jewish law on a subject and to find citations to primary sources that may be difficult to use. Ideally, these should be used as a gateway to the primary sources. However, there may be cases where the relevant primary source will be inaccessible either because it has not been translated or is unavailable generally in law school libraries.
There are several types of these contemporary treatises. First there are general treatises, addressing the whole body of Jewish law in general. An example of this kind, and by far the most valuable resource in conducting research in Jewish law, is Menachem Elon's JEWISH LAW: HISTORY, SOURCES, PRINCIPLES (International Collection BM520.5.E4313 1994). This is a four volume work that is essential for anyone conducting Jewish legal research. The second type of treatise is subject-specific treatises, addressing a single Jewish legal issue or a general subject area of Jewish law. An example of this type is Steven Friedell's Some Observations on the Talmudic Law of Tort,15 RUTGERS L.J. 897 (1984). (Anglo-American Periodicals Collection) or MEDICINE AND JEWISH LAW, edited by Fred Rosner (Treatise Collection BM538.H43 M43 1990).
Another type of treatise that may be helpful is the "how-to" books. These books offer advice about how to conduct research in Jewish law. Some of these books offer a general overview of the mechanics of studying Jewish law. Others offer detailed information about reading and interpreting a specific resource, most often the Talmud. Because Talmudic discussion can be very complicated these books will be invaluable for the non-expert who is delving into a page of Talmud.
Some examples contemporary treatises in the library's collection include:
- Everyman's Talmud: The Major Teachings of the Rabbinic Sages, by Abraham Cohen (Treatise Collection BM504.3.C63 1995).
- An Introduction To Jewish Civil Law, by Arnold Cohen (International Collection BM520.5.C63 1991).
- How Does Jewish Law Work, by J. Simcha Cohen (Treatise Collection BM522.27.O3624 1993).
- Jewish Law and Legal Theory, edited by Martin P. Golding (Treatise Collection BM520.6.G64 1993).
- Every Person's Guide to Jewish Law, by Ronald Issacs (International Collection KBM00.I82 2000).
- Modern Research In Jewish Law, edited by Bernard S. Jackson (International Collection K10.E74 Suppl. 1).
- Meta-Halakhah: Logic, Intuition and the Unfolding of Jewish Law, by Moshe Koppel (Treatise Collection BM520.5.K68 1997).
- Jewish Law: An Introduction, by Mendell Lewittes (International Collection KBM00.L48 1994).
- The Written and the Oral Torah: An Comprehensive Introduction, By Nathan T. Lopes Cardozo (Treatise Collection BM520.7.L65 1997).
- The Study of Talmud: Understanding the Halachic Mind, by Abraham Hirsch Rabinowitz (Treatise Collection BM520.6.R318 1996).
- Introduction to the Code of Maimonides (Mishneh Torah), by Isadore Twersky (International Collection KBM00.T83 1980).
- Studies in Jewish Law and Philosophy, by Isadore Twersky (Treatise Collection BM 520.5.T85 1982).
In sum, the research strategies outlined below for the legal codes, Talmud and responsa should be used in conjunction with contemporary treatises. These will help the non-expert wade through the vast body of Jewish law. Finding the right contemporary treatise is relatively simple. By entering "Jewish Law" or "Talmud"- into the library catalog's keyword search, BARON, almost all of the library's works on Jewish law will be retrieved. There are several excellent bibliographies and these are listed in Appendix F below.
The Written Law and the Oral Law
The founding document of Jewish law is split into two parts: the Written Law and Oral Law. Jewish tradition holds that the source of these two sets of laws is divine revelation. While this is not important to the scholar or law student conducting Jewish law research in the secular law school context, the practical purpose of this traditional belief for such secular study of Jewish law is that both the Written Law and the Oral Law are immutable and unchangeable. The two serve as a sort of "constitution" for the legal system, except that this constitution may never be amended or changed. The Written and Oral Law together are categorized as d'oraita (literally "Torah law" in Aramaic). D'oraita law is immutable and unchangeable.
The Written Law is found in the Torah, also known as the Pentateuch (Treatise Collection BS12222.L54 2001 or Treatise Collection BS1223 1994 or Treatise Collection BS1225.3.J78 1989). The Torah's 613 laws form the basis from which all Jewish law is derived. "Every section, verse and letter - indeed even every ornamentation on the letters - of the Torah has been recognized as an authoritative source of Jewish law." (3 MENACHEM ELON, JEWISH LAW: HISTORY, SOURCES, PRINCIPLES 1020 (1994).) The Torah and its laws are the fundamental source for the entire system of Jewish law.
However the Torah does not stand alone in Jewish law. In fact, despite its position at the apex of sources of Jewish law, citation to a Biblical law alone is rarely a sufficient source citation to Jewish law. "Citing the Hebrew Bible for any proposition without understanding the applicable Oral Law is an inherently dangerous business." (Chad Baruch & Karsten Lokken, Research of Jewish Law Issues: A Basic Guide and Bibliography For Students And Practitioners, 77 U. DET. MERCY. L. REV. 303, 308 (2000).) This may seem counter-intuitive. The "constitutional-level" laws found in the Torah should seem to be able to stand alone. However the purpose of the Oral Law is to clarify, compliment and supplement the laws written in the Torah. Essentially, the Oral Law provides guidance on the nature and applications of the Written Law and a reference to the Written Law without a reference to the Oral Law will almost never accurately describe the complete valid and current Jewish legal position on a given subject.
The main source for the Oral Law is a work called the Mishna (Treatise Collection BM497 1990). The Oral Law was initially handed down orally from generation to generation, until it was compiled and edited in 220 C.E. by Rabbi Judah Ha-Nasi (c. 135 C.E. - c. 220 C.E.). The historical period of the compilation and codification of the Oral law is called the (Tannaitic Period 1st Century C.E. -220 C.E.). The Mishna, largely organized by subject, "records the rules of the Oral Law as abstract, self-contained legal propositions" called mishnayot (lit. "mishnas"). An outline of the contents of the Mishna appears below in Appendix B.
In addition to the Mishna, there are other sources of the Oral Law. These sources are the halakhic midrashim (International Collection BM517.S63 A66 2002 (partial)) and the Tosefta (Treatise Collection BM508.13 E5 2002 (partial)). The halakhic midrashim are compilations of laws that correspond directly to a Written Law from the Torah. This is in contrast to the self-contained Oral Laws contained in the Mishna. Essentially the Mishna and the halakhic midrashim contain the Oral Law expressed in differing methodology of exegesis: mishnaic (self-contained) and midrashic (connected to a Written Law). (ELON at 1049.) The four major compilations of halakhic midrashim are listed on the outline in Appendix B. The Tosefta contains additional mishnayot not included in the final version of the edited Mishna.
In sum, the Written Law and Oral Law are the immutable (d'oraita) founding legal documents of the Jewish legal system. The source of the Written Law is found in the Torah. The Mishna is the major source of the Oral Law, but the halakhic midrashim and the tosefta are Oral Law sources as well. Laws developed after the close of the Mishna in 220 C.E. are not considered d'oraita, but rather d'rabbanan (Aramaic for rabbinical). In contrast to the d'oraita laws, d'rabbanan laws, made by rabbis, may be amended or modified, although no prescribed and universally accepted system exists for doing this.
The next primary source, and probably the most important source for the practical purpose of finding the law, is the Talmud. The Talmud is the source of thousands of d'rabbanan laws that were the result of rabbinical interpretation of the Mishna. The term "Talmud" is actually a bit misleading. The Talmud is actually a collective term for several individual works that are printed together in the same set of volumes. The Talmud consists of the Mishna (discussed above), the Gemara, and several commentaries on these works. In other words, the Talmud contains the text of the Oral Law, serves as the primary source of the d'rabbanan laws and also contains commentaries whose authority has risen to the level of a primary source of Jewish law. Therefore, as a package, the Talmud (with the Torah) is the the most important source of Jewish law.
The Gemara was developed in the Amoraic period (220 C.E.-500 C.E.) which was the first historical period after the close of the Mishna. The text of the Gemara records and reports seven generations-worth of debates and statements of the rabbis of the great academies of the Land of Israel and Babylonia. Put simply: as the rabbis of the Mishna argued about the Torah, the rabbis of the Gemara argued about the Mishna. (MELVIN KONNER, UNSETTLED: AN ANTHROPOLOGY OF THE JEWS 95 (2003).) The focus of the Gemara is the interpretation and application of the Mishna. These recorded debates and statements result in thousands of d'rabbanan laws that form the bulk of Jewish law today.
There are actually two different Gemara that appear in two different Talmuds: (1) the Babylonian Talmud or Talmud Bavli (containing the Gemara emanating from the academies of Babylonia) (Treatise Collection BM506.B6 E5 1997 or Treatise Collection BM499.5.E5 1965); and (2) the Jerusalem Talmud or Talmud Yerushalmi (containing the Gemara emanating from the academies of the Land of Israel). The Babylonian Talmud is the more complete and more widely used and cited of the two. When one refers to "the Talmud," this almost universally refers to the Babylonian Talmud.
The Post-Talmudic legal scholars are separated into three historical sub-periods: geonim (700-1050), reshonim (1050-1599), and aharonim (1600-today). The legal literature of these periods can be separated into three rough genres: (1) commentaries on the Talmud; (2) law codes; and (3) responsa (case law). (3 ELON at 1101-1102.) Each of these types of literature will be addressed in turn in the following three subsections.
Research Strategy: Basic Structure of the Babylonian Talmud
The structure of the Talmud tracks the structure of the Mishna, therefore it is necessary to first understand how the Mishna is structured. The Mishna is divided into six "orders" (seder-sing. sedarim-pl.), each dealing with a subject area: (1) Zeraim (lit.-seeds) dealing with agricultural and food laws; (2) Moed (lit.-holidays) - laws relating to holiday and Sabbath rituals; (3) Nashim (lit.-women) laws relating to marriage and divorce; (4) Nezikin (lit.-damages) laws of tort, other civil law and criminal law; (5) Kodoshim (lit.-holy things) laws relating to the Temple sacrifice and ritual; and (6) Taharot (lit.-purity) laws relating to ritual purity. Each order is divided into tractates (masekhet-sing. masekhot-pl.). Each tractate is divided into chapters and each chapter is made of up individual laws called mishnayot (mishna-sing.). See Appendix B below for a complete listing of the tractates of the Mishna. The Talmud is divided into tractates and chapters that track the tractates and chapters of the Mishna. It is important to note, however, that the Talmud does not contain a tractate for every Mishna tractate. In the listing of Mishna tractates in Appendix B, tractates marked with a "*" indicate that a Talmud tractate corresponds to that Mishna tractate.
The Talmud, tracking the tractate and chapter divisions of the Misnha, is also divided by page number. The pages, also called folios, follow the following system: 2a, 2b, 3a, 3b, 4a, 4b, etc. The numbering begins from the beginning with each new tractate, but there is not a page 1a or 1b. Each tractate begins with page 2a. All of the page information appears at the top of each page: chapter name, chapter number, tractate name, and page number. It is important to note, that in the untranslated Talmud, all of the page and chapter numbers are written in Hebrew characters, not in Arabic numerals. The Schottenstein translation contains all of this information in English on the translation page. Citations to the Talmud are to the tractate name and the page number. For example, in the citation "TB Baba Batra 29a", the "TB" refers to the Talmud Bavli (Hebrew for Babylonian Talmud), the tractate is Baba Batra and the folio is number 29a.
Research Strategy: Understanding How a Hebrew/Aramaic Page of the Babylonian Talmud is Constructed
Even when researching the Talmud in English, it is beneficial to understand how the page is constructed in the Hebrew and Aramaic. As discussed above the pages of the Talmud are set up in a unique fashion. The different works that make up the Talmud (Mishna, Gemara, commentaries) are all placed together on the same page. In a sense, each page of Talmud contains a conversation whose participants are diverse historically (spanning over a thousand years) and geographically (they lived in places as varied as Babylonia (in present-day Iraq) and France). Understanding this unique set-up is helpful to understanding a translation, even if not a word of Hebrew is understood. While all the pages do not look identical, the basic structure is similar:
- Central Section. The central column of the Talmud page contains the text of both the Mishna and the Gemara. The structure of this column is as follows:
- Text from the Mishna will appear first, usually a single law. Immediately following the Mishna text, the text of the Gemara will begin (often on the same line).
- The Gemara text discusses, interprets and expands upon the immediately preceding Mishna text.
- After the Gemara completes its extended discussion on the preceding Mishna, (this may be several pages), the next law from Mishna will appear, followed by Gemara text addressing this next mishna.
- There are signals (an Aramaic abbreviation for Mishna and Gemara) indicating when the text switches from Mishna to Gemara and back again. This signal is in a slightly larger typeface than the texts of the Mishna and Gemara.
- The Mishna text is in Hebrew and the Gemara text is in Aramaic, although they will look the same to the untrained eye.
- Central Inside Margin. This section contains Rashi's commentary on the Talmud.
- Central Outside Margin. This section contains the Tosefot commentary on the Talmud.
- Extreme Inside and Outside Margin Notes. Notes and commentaries have been added over the centuries. These may vary page to page but two common ones are:
- Ein Mishpat Ner Mitzvah - complied by Yehoshua Boaz in Italy in the 1500s, these notation provide the citations to legal codes that relate to the Talmudic discussion on that page.
Masoret ha-Shas - these margin notes provide Talmudic citations to other tractates that are relevant to the page's discussion and offers citations to other works that are relevant to the page's discussion.
Research Strategy: Using Translations of the Talmud
The major translations usually do not follow this physical structure of a central column and margin columns. Also, most do not contain full translations of Rashi, Tosefot or the extreme margin commentaries. Although this research guide focuses on the Schottenstein Edition it will also refer to the Soncino Edition. (THE HEBREW ENGLISH EDITION OF THE BABYLONIAN TALMUD (1989). ( Treatise Collection BM499.5.E5 1965).) in contrast to the Schottenstein Edition.
The Schottenstein Edition uses a unique system for its translation. First, the Hebrew/Aramaic page used is the classic "Vilna edition" folios that have been the standard edition since its publication in 1886. The Hebrew/Aramaic page is on one side of the open volume and its translation is on the opposite page. However, the translation of one of the Hebrew/Aramaic folios takes several English pages. For example, it takes two pages of English translation to translate page 28a of tractate Baba Batra. Sticking to the practice of keeping the Hebrew/Aramaic page opposite the English translation page, the editors include the complete page 28a opposite each of the two pages translating it. In other words, the Hebrew/Aramaic page "28a" appears twice. A gray bar along the central column of the Hebrew/ Aramaic (Mishna/Gemara) denotes portion is translated on the opposite page. On the English page, the first page of translation of 28a is indicated with a superscript number: 28a1. The second page is labeled "28a2." Pages that take more than two pages to translate are numbered with superscripts "3 ", " 4 ", etc. These page numbers appear on the top margin of the page along with the chapter name, chapter number and tractate name. Therefore the top margin of the first translation page of page 28a of tractate Baba Batra reads:
CHEZAKAS HABATIM CHAPTER THREE BAVA BASRA 28a1
(Note that "Baba Batra" is the same thing as "Bava Basra." In Hebrew, many words may be properly pronounced in two different ways with interchangeable letters. In many words a "b" is interchangeable with a "v" sound. The same rule can apply to the "t" and "s" sounds).
There is only a full translation of the center column (Mishna/Gemara). The beginning of a Mishna is noted by the term "Mishna" in large letters and the beginning of a Gemara is noted in the same way. In general, the Mishna portion is short, usually only a portion of one page and the Gemara can be as long as several pages. The center column of many pages will be only Gemara text and no Mishna text will appear.
The translation section, which appears on the top portion of the English page, is made up of bold type and normal type. The bold type is the word for word translation of the Mishna or Gemara that is supplemented with language in "normal-type" that has the effect of making the language flow in English and therefore be more understandable. This is one of the major advantages of the Schottenstein edition. The "normal-type" supplements allow for more a readable translation than a straight translation, but the bold type still indicates what the actual language of the Mishna or Gemara states. Furthermore, embedded in the English is the Hebrew/Aramaic text. Each bold type word for word translation phrase is accompanied with the Hebrew/Aramaic text. This may make reading the translation a little more difficult, since the text is interrupted with Hebrew characters, but this system was probably intended to help people with a basic knowledge of Hebrew learn how to study the text in the original language. However, it is still relatively easy to skip over the Hebrew phrases and read only the bold translations and the "normal type" supplements that together form a readable translation of the Mishna and the Gemara. (The Soncino edition is more of a traditional translation, one page of Hebrew/Aramaic for one page of English. Also, the Soncino does not use the bold system to denote exact word for word translation versus supplementary language to make the text flow. Finally, the translation page is entirely English, uninterrupted by any Hebrew or Aramaic. Other editions and translations may use different methods to effectively translate the Hebrew and Aramaic text.)
As stated above, the Schottenstein edition only translates the center column of the Talmud page, consisting of the Mishna and the Gemara. The Rashi, Tosefot and margin notes are not translated. However, each page contains extensive explanatory footnotes that are drawn from these sources as well as from commentaries not appearing on the Talmud page. Through these footnotes a significant portion of the Rashi, Tosefot and other commentaries are included in the English, but they are not translated in completion and in a way that corresponds directly to the Hebrew text.
Another helpful feature is the English language introductions. In the Schottenstein edition, each tractate and each chapter within a tractate contain an introductory essay. These essays are very helpful in introducing the topics that will be discussed in the tractate and chapter. The Soncino edition only contains tractate introductions. Another resource available are the guides to Talmud study and interpretation. A bibliography of these is listed at Appendix F.
There are also numerous authoritative commentaries that do not appear within the pages of the Talmud. Dovid Landesman's book, A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO TORAH LEARNING (Treatise Collection BM503.5.L36 1995) contains extensive citations to the classic commentaries on the Talmud and Mishna, as well as citations to other works of Jewish law. (LANDESMAN, at 9-34 (1995).)
Authoritative commentaries on the Mishna that include R. Moshe ben Maimon's (Rambam or Maimonides) (1135-1204) commentary on the Mishna, R. Ovadiah of Bertinoro's (Bartinura) (c.1450-c.1515) commentary on the Mishna and Tosfot Yom Tov by Yom Tov Lipmann Heller (1579-1654). These are also not inserted onto the Talmud page. Dovid Landesman's book, A PRACTICAL GUIDE TO TORAH LEARNING (Treatise Collection BM503.5.L36 1995) contains extensive citations to the classic commentaries on the Talmud and Mishna, as well as citations to other works of Jewish law. (LANDESMAN, at 9-34 (1995).)
3. Law Codes
The Talmud is not a strictly legal source. It examines religious, ethical, moral and philosophical subjects as well as legal issues. Furthermore, the legal issues are intertwined with the non-legal subjects (called aggada). Even the legal discussions often flow from topic to topic, exploring disagreements among rabbis and often without stating a clear, concise and final rule. Finally, although the thematic pattern of the Mishna is followed, laws addressing almost any subject can be addressed in any part. In other words, laws of the same subject will not always appear together. The result of all of this is that it can be extremely difficult to find an actual law from within the Talmud (and therefore its commentaries).
The authoritative law codes provide a solution to this problem. Rabbis have undertaken the enormous task of creating comprehensive law codes by separating out the actual laws from the great Talmudic discussions and putting them together by subject. These are an extremely helpful resource, especially since these authoritative codes have the force of law themselves. Major codes include:
- Maimonides' Mishneh Torah (International Collection KBM00.M3 1967 (partial translation) or International Collection KBM520.84 A213 1949 (partial translation) or International Collection-Miami Classification 247MaK (partial translation)) - This work, sometimes called Code of Maimonides or Yad ha-Chazakah, codifies almost 15,000 laws from the Talmud. Mishneh Torah is often also referred to as the "Rambam," an abbreviation for Maimonides' name. Mishneh Torah took Maimonides ten years to complete and dates from the 1170s and 1180s. Exact dates are unknown. (3 ELON at 1188.) Although Mishneh Torah was controversial when published because no Talmudic source for each law is listed, today Mishneh Torah is considered an authoritative statement of Jewish law. Mishneh Torah can properly be considered a primary source for the law and there are many commentaries written on the Mishneh Torah itself, several tracing the Talmudic sources of Maimonides' statement of the laws.
- Yosef Karo's (1488-1575) Shulchan Aruch (International Collection KMK1572.Qu5 (partial translation) or International Collection-Miami Classification 247 Ca (partial translation)) - The Shulchan Aruch, completed in 1565, is probably the most important of the legal codes. For hundreds of years it has been accepted as the final and authoritative codification of the laws found in the Talmud. (3 ELON at 1368-1422.) Even the work's title indicates its authority. Shulchan Aruch translates as "set table," thereby symbolically stating that the Jewish law has finally be set and settled in a clear code. (It should be noted that the authoritative code of Jewish law is the Shulchan Aruch along with glosses on the Shulchan Aruch added by Moshe Isserles (c. 1525-1572), also called Rama or Remu, that present legal opinions omitted by Karo, especially opinions specific to the Ashkenazic (German and Eastern European) Jewish customs. The glosses are called the "table cloth" to the "set table" of the Shulchan Aruch. The two together still form the definitive codification of Jewish law. 3 ELON at 1359-1365.) In contrast to the Mishneh Torah which codifies the entire body of Jewish law, the Shulchan Aruch codifies only the laws that were applicable in Karo's time (and, for the most part, today; i.e., laws applicable for the rites of the Temple in Jerusalem are omitted).
- The Shulchan Aruch is actually a companion work to Bet Yosef (also by Karo). Bet Yosef is a compendium of material and sources for the laws that were applicable after the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem (in the year 70 C.E.). For each of these laws, Karo cites the Talmudic source and presents all the different opinions on the law from over 30 of the authoritative works. He then concludes which of the opinions should be followed. (3 ELON at 1316)
- The Shulchan Aruch is the clear and definitive statement of the law based upon his conclusions in Bet Yosef. Sources and differing opinions are omitted in the Shulchan Aruch but may be referenced from the Bet Yosef.
A third authoritative code is the Arba'ah Turim (also called the "Tur") by Jacob ben Asher (c.1270-c.1343). Along with the Mishneh Torah, the Tur served as the foundation of the Shulchan Aruch, which follows the organizational structure of the Tur.
Research Strategy: Using Law Codes
If it is necessary to start with primary sources, the codes may be an easier starting point for the non-expert than having to start with the Talmud. The most authoritative codes of Jewish law are: Maimonides' Mishneh Torah and Karo's Shulchan Aruch. It is important to note that there are other authoritative codes besides these, especially the code titled Arba'ah Turim or Tur, but because the Tur is probably not commonly held in law school libraries, the Mishneh Torah and the Shulchan Aruch will effectively serve the purposes most Jewish law research questions.
Mishneh Torah. The Mishneh Torah (Mishneh Torah should not be confused with Mishna as they are two different works of Jewish law.) is divided into 14 books each stating the laws of a single subject. Each book is divided into subject-area sections (titled "Laws of" or "Hilchot"). Each section is further divided into chapters and each chapter is divided into paragraphs. Each paragraph constitutes a single law. Laws in the Mishneh Torah are cited by section name, chapter number, and paragraph number. For example in the citation "MT, Nizkei Mamon 1:1" the MT stands for Mishneh Torah, Nizkei Mamon is the subject-area section and the 1:1 refers to chapter 1, paragraph 1.
The vast majority of civil and criminal laws (as opposed to laws dealing with religious observance) are found in Books 4, 11, 12, 13, and 14. These books contain laws relating to divorce, damages, sales, contracts, employment, inheritance, evidence and many others. The subject-area divisions and subdivisions (which are listed in Appendix D) make finding a specific law relatively simple by narrowing down where a law will be located. The tables of contents and indexes if included within a particular edition will also be helpful in locating a law.
Shulchan Aruch. The Shulchan Aruch is divided into four parts. Each of the four parts is divided into sections (halachot); each section is subdivided into chapters (simanim); and each chapter is subdivided into paragraphs, each containing a law (se'ifim). The four parts are Orach Chaim (laws addressing daily religious ritual observance), Yoreh De'ah (laws addressing ritual observances such as kashrut, circumcision burial and mourning), Even ha-Ezer (family law), and Hoshen Mishpat (civil and criminal laws).
The Shulchan Aruch is cited by part, chapter and paragraph: Sh. Ar. HM 201:1. "HM" is the part Hoshen Mishpat; "201" is the chapter number; and "1" is the paragraph number. The sections are given names, but they are not included in the citation as they are in the Mishneh Torah citations. See Appendix E for a subject outline of the chapter divisions of Shulchan Aruch, part Hoshen Mishpat.
An unabridged translation of the entire Shulchan Aruch has not yet been published. The common abridged translations contain a table of contents and/or indices that are relatively simple to use and locate laws on a specific subject-area. Emanuel Quint's work, A RESTATEMENT OF RABBINIC CIVIL LAW (International Collection KMK1572.Qu5), although not a direct translation of the Shulchan Aruch, restates the civil laws enumerated Shulchan Aruch, part Hoshen Mishpat, following its exact chapter divisions. This book is essential to any non-expert seeking to use the Shulchan Aruch.
There are also numerous commentaries on the Shulchan Aruch that are considered authoritative primary sources of law themselves. Some of these are traditional commentaries, explaining the Shulchan Aruch in detail, and others follow the codificatory form even updating the Shulchan Aruch with rulings that postdate its publication. Some of these commentaries are more common in law libraries than selections of the Shulchan Aruch itself. (Some of these "code-updates" and commentaries have titles that are very similar to Shulchan Aruch, and should not be confused with the original by Karo. An example is Aruch Ha-Shulchan by Yechiel Michel Epstein (1829-1908). Another example is Kitzur Shulchan Aruch (Treatise Collection BM520.9.G3513 1991) by Shlomo Ganzfried (1804-1886) which is a concise statement of the laws of Shulchan Aruch part Orach Chaim. Confusing things even further is the title Mishna Berurah by Yisrael Kagan (1838-1933) (the "Chafetz Chaim"), which is also a major commentary on Shulchan Aruch and not the similarly-named Mishna.)
Compilations of Responsa (written rabbinical opinions on legal disputes or issues) are a third type of post-Talmudic literature and primary source of law. The responsa literature is the "case law" of Jewish law, consisting of the decisions of rabbis that responded to questions of Jewish law submitted in writing. Questions would be submitted to a local rabbi who would then pass the question up to great scholar of Jewish law, who would answer the question. The following sections will discuss responsa in the three post-Talmudic historical periods.
- Geonic Period (7th Century - mid-11th Century). During this period, questions were mainly submitted by members of Jewish communities in Spain and North Africa. Questions would be screened by scholars in Egypt before being sent on to the academies of Babylonia. Upon reaching the academies, the questions would be debated, answered and sent back along the same route they arrived. The compilation and organization of these early responsa can best be described as sketchy and much has been lost to history. (3 ELON at 1472.) Further, many of the compilations have not been translated into English. An important compilation is Otzar Ha-Geonim, published by Benjamin M. Lewin in the 1920s and 1930s. In this work, the responsa are organized by subject in the sequence of the Babylonian Talmud.
- Period of the Rishonim (mid-11th Century - 16th Century). This has been called the "classic" period of responsa. (3 ELON at 1472.) During this period, a more detailed form of responsum developed. Also, the responses were given from many different centers of Jewish learning, rather than a single city, as in the geonic period. As a result, often these decisions were addressed to, and thus only binding upon, the community from which the question came. Major respondents of this period include R. Yitzchak Alfasi (1013-1103), R. Yaakov ben Meir (Rabbenu Tam) (1100-1171), Maimonides, Nachmanides, and R. Shlomo ben Aderes (Rashba) (1235-1310).
Period of the Ahronim (16th Century - present). During this period, the source of the responsa shifted from Spain to Eastern Europe, Turkey, the Balkans, the Land of Israel, North Africa and eventually even the United States. The "Vilna Gaon" is one of the main responders of this period. Other respondents of this period included R. Meir of Lublin (Maharam) (1558-1616), Moshe Isserles (Rama or Remu) (c. 1525-1572), R. Shlomo Luria (Maharshal) (1510-1574), and Yosef Karo. The major American work of responsa is Responsa Iggerot Moshe by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein (1895-1986), After the publication of the Shulchan Aruch, compilations of responsa usually follow the subject structure of the Shulchan Aruch.
Research Strategy: Using Responsa
Researching the responsa will be difficult, especially for the non-expert. There exists today 300,000 known responsa in 3000 books by dozens of authors. (3 ELON at 1462.) There is no comprehensive digest of all of these decisions. Compilations of responsa are the main tool to locate responsa on a specific topic. After the publication of the Shulchan Aruch, most compilations of responsa are organized according to the subject order of the Shulchan Aruch. While each individual compilation may be organized by topic, these decisions are not organized, indexed or digested across different compilations. Most are not translated into English. There is not even a comprehensive list of the compilations, let alone the individual decisions.
The best available strategy is to locate several major translated compilations and check each for the desired topic. Menacham Elon's JEWISH LAW: HISTORY, SOURCES, PRINCIPLES contains an extensive bibliography of compilations of responsa (International Collection BM520.5.E4313 1994).
In sum, Jewish law begins with the laws contained in the Written Law (the Torah) and the Oral Law (primarily the Mishna, but also the Halakhic Midrashim and Tosefta). The laws in these sources form the immutable (d'oraita) "constitution" of Jewish law. After the close of the Mishna, rabbis interpreted, studied and applied the laws contained in the Written and Oral Law and the result was numerous new laws created by rabbis (d'rabbanan). The Talmud (Gemara and its commentaries along with the text of the Mishna) records, explains and interprets the rabbinical discussions of seven generations that results in the body of d'rabbanan law. This large body of law is codified in clear definitive statements in the great law codes. Finally, the even larger body of responsa or case law records how these laws were applied by rabbis in real life situations. Contemporary treatises are helpful tools both as guide to using the primary sources and to the substance of the law itself.
While the previous paragraph sums up the main body of primary sources of Jewish law discussed in this Research Guide, there are other primary sources. These include the full Hebrew Bible or Tanakh (the Torah plus the Prophets and Writings), commentaries on the Hebrew Bible, aggadic midrashim (interpretation of the ethical and philosophical component of the Written and Oral Law), additional commentaries on the Talmud, commentaries on the major commentaries of the Talmud, commentaries on the major codes, major ethical works, rabbinical and communal enactments (called takkanot) and legal documents such as marriage contracts (ketubot).
An understanding of what the basic primary sources are, what they contain, how they are structured and their authoritativeness is necessary before researching Jewish law. The above explanation of these features of Jewish law is narrow in the number of primary sources discussed and basic in the explanation of those sources. However, this concise summary will offer the basic knowledge to begin to conduct research in Jewish law and to understand the fruits of that research.
Appendix A: Concise Jewish Law Primary Source Outline
Written Law - Torah
1. Oral Law (Tannaitic Period, 1st Century C.E. - 220 C.E.)
- Halakhic Midrashim
2. Amoraic Period (220 C.E. - 500 C.E.)
- Babylonian Talmud
- Jerusalem Talmud
3. Post-Talumdic Period (Geonim: 7th Century - mid-11th Century; Rishonim: mid-11th Century - 16th Century; Ahronim: 16th Century - present)
- Commentaries on Mishna/Talmud
- Codes of Law
Other resources including takkanot (enactments), legal forms, and legal documents
Appendix B: Expanded Jewish Law Primary Source Outline
1. Written Law - Torah
- Genesis (Bereshit)
- Exodus (Shemot)
- Leviticus (Vayikra)
- Numbers (Bamidbar)
- Deuteronomy (D'varim)
2. Oral Law - Tannaitic Period (1 C.E. - 220 C.E.)
- Mishna - Structure of the Mishna: divided into six orders (seder, sing.; sedarim, pl.), each subdivided into several tractates (masekhet, sing.; masekhtot, pl.). Each masekhet is divided into chapters.
- Zeraim - (lit.-seeds) - agricultural and food laws
- Maaser Sheni
- Moed - (lit.-holidays) - lawsrelating to holiday and Sabbath rituals
- Rosh Hashanah*
- Moed Katan*
- Nashim - (lit.-women) - laws relating to marriage and divorce
- Nezikin - (lit.-damages) - laws of tort, other civil law, criminal law
- Baba Kamma*
- Baba Metzia*
- Baba Batra*
- Avodah Zarah*
- Avot (also known as Pirkei Avot, Ethics of the Fathers)
- Kodoshim - (lit.-holy things) - laws relating to Temple sacrifice and ritual slaughter
- Tahorot - (lit.-purity) - laws of ritual purity
- Zeraim - (lit.-seeds) - agricultural and food laws
- Halakhic Midrashim
- Mekhilta - on Exodus (Shemot)
- Sifra - on Leviticus (Vayikra)
- Sifrei - On Numbers (Bamidbar)
- Sifrei - On Deuteronomy (D'varim)
3. Amoraic Period - (220 C.E. - 500 C.E..)
- Gemara (Babylonian Talmud or Talmud Bavli) - The Gemara tracks the order of the Mishna. Not all tractates of the Mishna are addressed. Those that are addressed are indicated with a " * " in the listing of the Mishna tractates above.
- Jerusalem Talmud or Talmud Yerushalmi
4. Post-Talumdic Period (Geonim: 7th Century - mid-11th Century; Rishonim: mid-11th Century - 16th Century; Ahronim: 16th Century - present)
- Major commentaries on Mishna/Gemara
- Numerous Others
- Codes of Law
- Mishneh Torah - written by Maimonides (RAMBAM)
- Arba'ah Turim
- Shulchan Aruch
- Responsa (Case Law)
Other resources including takkanot (enactments), legal forms, and legal documents
Appendix C: Anatomy of One Law
Appendix D: Breakdown of Civil/Criminal Law Contents of the Mishneh Torah
Note: Books 4 and 11-14 of Mishneh Torah and the Shulchan Aruch part Hoshen Mishpat cover much of the same material, but in very different orders.
Mishneh Torah Civil Law Subject List
Book 4: Sefer Nashim (Book of Women)
- Hilchot Ishut (Laws of Personal Status)
- Hilchot Gerushin (Laws of Divorce)
- Hilchot Yibbum va-Chalitzah (Laws of Levirate Marriage and Release Therefrom)
- Hilchot Na'arah Betulah (Laws of Unmarried Women)
- Hilchot Sotah (Laws of the Suspected Wife)
Book 11: Sefer Nezikin (Book of Damages)
- Hilchot Nizkei Mamon (Laws of Damages Caused by Property)
- Hilchot Genevah (Laws of Theft)
- Hilchot Gezelah va-Avedah (Laws of Robbery and Lost Property)
- Hilchot Chovel u-Mazzik (Laws of Wounding and Damaging)
- Hilchot Rotzeah u-Shemirat ha-Nefesh (Laws of Homicide and Preservation of Life)
Book 12: Sefer Kinyan (Book of Acquisition)
- Hilchot Mechirah (Laws of Sales)
- Hilchot Zechiyah u-Matanah (Laws of Entitlements and Gifts)
- Hilchot Sechenim (Laws of Neighbors)
- Hilchot Sheluchin v'Sutafin (Laws of Agency and Partnership)
- Hilchot Avadim (Laws of Slaves)
Book 13: Sefer Mishpatim (Book of Civil Laws)
- Hilchot Sechirut (Laws of Leasing and Hiring)
- Hilchot She'elah u-Fikadon (Laws of Borrowing and Bailment)
- Hilchot Malveh ve-Loveh (Laws of Creditor and Debtor)
- Hilchot To-en ve-Nitan (Laws of Plaintiff and Defendant)
- Hilchot Nachalot (Laws of Inheritance)
Book 14: Sefer Shoftim (Book of Judges)
- Hilchot ha-Sanhedrin v'ha-Onshin ha-Mesurin Lahen (Laws of Sanhedrin and Its Penal Jurisdiction)
- Hilchot Edut (Laws of Evidence)
- Hilchot Mamrim (Laws of Rebels)
- Hilchot Evel (Laws of Mourning)
Hilchot Melachim u-Milchamoteihem (Laws of Kings and Their Wars)
Appendix E: Breakdown of Civil/Criminal Law Contents of the Shulchan Aruch
Chapter Divisions ofShulchan Aruch, part Hoshen Mishpat (the Civil Laws)
Laws of Judges
Laws of Evidence
Laws of Loans
Hilchot To’en v’Nitan
Laws of Plaintiff & Defendant
Hilchot Giviyat Mivah
Laws of Loan Collection
Hilchot Giviyat Hov m’Yetomim
Laws of Collection of Debt from Orphans
Hilchot Giviyat Hov m’Nechasim
Laws of Collection of Debt from Encumbered Property
Laws of Mortgages
Hilchot ha-Oseh Shaleach Ligbot Hov
Laws of Appointment of Agent to Collect Debt
Laws of Powers of Attorney
Laws of Suretyship
Hilchot Hezkat Metaltelin
Laws of Possession of Personal Property
Hilchot Hezkat Karka’ot
Laws of Possession of Land
Hilchot Nizkei Shechenim
Laws of Damages of Neighbors
Hilchot Shutafim b’Karka
Laws of Concurrent Owners of Land
171-175 para. 4
Hilchot Halukat Shutafut
Laws of Dissolution of Joint Ownership
175 para. 5 - end 175
Laws of Adjoining Landowners
Laws of Partnership
Laws of Agency
Hilchot Mikach u-Mimkhar
Laws of Purchase and Sale
Hilchot Ona’ah u-Mikach Ta’ut
Laws of Overreaching and Transactions Resulting from Mistake
Laws of Gifts
Hilchot Matanat Shechiv Me’ra
Laws of Gifts of a Person Dangerously Ill or Reasonably Apprehending Imminent Death
Hilchot Avedah u-Metzi’ah
Laws of Lost and Found Objects
Hilchot Perikah u-Te’ina v’Din
Laws of Unloading and Reloading Overloaded Animals
Laws of Travelers
Hilchot Hefker v’Nichsei ha Ger
Laws of Ownerless Property and Property of Proselytes
Laws of Inheritance
Laws of the Guardian, Administrator or Trustee
Laws of Pledges
Hilchot Shomer Sachar
Laws of Paid Bailee
Laws of Craftsmen
Laws of Lessee
Hilchot Hakirut v’Kabbelanut
Laws of Sharecropping
Hilchot Sechirut Po’alim
Laws of Hiring Laborers
Laws of Borrowing
Laws of Theft
Laws of Robbery
Laws of Damages
Hilchot M’abed Mamon Chavero u-Masira
Laws of Destroying Another's Property and of Informers
Hilchot Nizkei Mamon
Laws of Damages Caused by Property
Hilchot Chovel ba-Chavero
Laws of Injuring Another (Assault and Battery)
Hilchot Shmirat ha-Nefesh
Laws of Removing Life-Threatening Risks and Erecting a Parapet on One's Roof
*Elon presents these divisions with cross references for the corresponding sections of the Mishneh Torah and the Shulchan Aruch. Elon supra n.
Appendix F: Bibliography of Published Bibliographies and Contemporary Treatises
Bibliographies of Primary Sources, Contemporary Treatises and Talmud Interpretation Guides
- Weisbard, Phyllis Holman and David Schonberg. Jewish Law: Bibliography of Sources and Scholarship in English. Littleton, CO: Fred B. Rothman & Co. (1989). (Treatise Collection BM520.3.W45 1989) - This bibliography is extremely helpful, containing over 500 pages of citations of primary sources (including compilations of responsa) and contemporary treatises.
- Chad Baruch & Karsten Lokken, Research of Jewish Law Issues: A Basic Guide and Bibliography For Students And Practitioners, 77 U. DET. MERCY. L. REV. 303 (1999-2000). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Samuel J. Levine, Teaching Jewish Law in American Law Schools: An Emerging Development in Law and Religion, 26 FORDHAM URB. L.J. 1041 (1999). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Weisbard, Phyllis Holman, Basic Books and Periodicals on Jewish Law: A Guide for Law Librarians, 82 LAW LIBR. J. 519 (1990). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
Select Annotated Citations of Contemporary Treatises
- Abrams, Judith Z. The Babylonian Talmud, A Topical Guide. New York: University Press of America, 2002. (Treatise Collection BM504.A26 2002) - This work provides a topical outline of the Talmud. It is organized according to the order of the Talmud.
- Cohen, Abraham. Everyman's Talmud: The Major Teachings of the Rabbinic Sages. New York: Schocken, 1949. (Treatise Collection BM504.3.C63 1995) - This books contains a summary of the substance of the major laws in the Talmud. It is organized in the order of the Talmud and is peppered with historical information to put the laws in context.
- Dorff, Elliot N. and Arthur Rosett. A Living Tree, The Roots and Growth of Jewish Law. Albany, N.Y.: State University of New York Press, 1988. (International Collection-Miami Classification 247 Do71) - This work is an accessible guide to Jewish legal resources and their historical development. To enhance their explanation of the Jewish legal system, Dorff and Rosett use analogies to other legal systems, including the American system. This device will be helpful for the law student, lawyer and American legal scholar, not well-versed in Jewish law.
- Elon, Menachem. Jewish Law: History, Sources, Principles. Phildadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1994. (International Collection BM520.5.E4313 1994) - It would be impossible to overstate the importance of this work. Menacham Elon, a former justice of the Israel Supreme Court, and now a professor at the Hebrew University School of Law, is the world's foremost scholar of Jewish law in the context of law school study (as opposed to yeshiva study). This four-volume set is the seminal treatise on both the substance of Jewish and the sources of Jewish law. Elon's focus is Mishpat-ha-Ivri, the civil law component of the Jewish legal system. These volumes are essential to guide the student and practitioner through the process and sources of Jewish law. Elon details the historic development of Jewish law, addresses many substantive issues in Jewish law and includes invaluable guides to Jewish law research, including a list of responsa compilations and subject cross-reference table for the Shulchan Aruch and the Mishneh Torah.
- Feigenbaum, Yitzchak. Understanding the Talmud. New York: Feldheim Publishers, 1988. (Treatise Collection BM503.6.F45 1988) - This book provides a guide to the syntax and language structure of the Talmud to aid the beginner in interpretation and understanding of the text. This book is intended to aid those seeking to study Talmud in the original Hebrew and Aramaic.
- Issacs, Ronald H. Every Person's Guide to Jewish Law. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, Inc., 2000. (International Collection KBM00.I82 2000) - This work gives a history of Jewish law and its major sources. It also contains a chapter telling legends associated with Jewish law and a glossary of Jewish law topics.
- Landesman, Dovid. A Practical Guide to Torah Learning. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc., 1995. (Treatise Collection BM503.5.L36 1995) - Although its target audience is religiously motivated students and scholars, this book contains much information that will be valuable to the law school student or scholar of Jewish law. Especially helpful is its extensive bibliography of classic primary Jewish law sources and its sample analysis of a Talmudic discussion.
- Lewittes, Mendell. Jewish Law: An Introduction. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc., 1994. (International Collection KBM00.L48 1994) - This book provides an overview of both the history and sources of Jewish law from ancient times until contemporary times, including information on contemporary responses of Jewish law to modern technology. Lewittes also makes references lesser-known works of Jewish law.
- Lopes Cardozo, Nathan T. The Written and the Oral Torah: A Comprehensive Introduction. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc., 1997. (Treatise Collection BM520.7.L65 1997) - Lopes Cardozo provides a detailed exposition on the nature, history, structure and philosophy of the Written Law and the Oral Law (including Tosefta and halakhic midrashim in addition to the Mishna. There is also a chapter on the classic rules of interpretation of these works.
- Neusner , Jacob. How The Talmud Works. Boston: Brill (2002). (Treatise Collection BM503.6.N477 2002) - This book is a relatively advanced guide to structure and organization of the Babylonian Talmud. It includes detailed and somewhat complicated analysis of Talmudic discussions and contains a bibliography of Neusner's extensive writings on Jewish law.
- Quint, Emanuel. A Restatement of Rabbinic Civil Law. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson, Inc. 1990. (International Collection KMK1572.Qu5) - This multivolume work, although not a direct translation of the Shulchan Aruch, restates the civil laws enumerated Shulchan Aruch, part Hoshen Mishpat, following its exact chapter divisions. This book is essential to any lay person seeking to use the Shulchan Aruch.
Helpful Internet Sites
- Eliezer Segal's official Web site (accessed January 12, 2005) - This site is maintained by Eliezer Siegel, professor of Jewish History at the University of Calgary. On site is excellent information about the sources of Jewish law and their organization. Professor Siegel includes many images of "typical" pages from many of the sources.
Jewish Law: Examining Halacha, Jewish Issues and Secular Law (an online journal) (January 12, 2005) - This site, called "Jewish Law: Examining Halacha, Jewish Issues and Secular Law," is an electronic journal of Jewish law, containing articles, forms, commentary, case summaries and other information regarding Jewish law. There are also links to articles published by other law journals on topics related to Jewish law.
Bibliography of this Research Guide
- The Artscroll Series/Schottenstein Edition Talmud Bavli. Brooklyn, NY: Mesorah Publications 2001. (Treatise Collection BM506.B6 E6 1997).
- The Hebrew English Edition of the Babylonian Talmud. London: Soncino Press, 1989. (Treatise Collection BM499.5.E5 1965).
- Dorff, Elliot N. and Arthur Rosett. A Living Tree, The Roots and Growth of Jewish Law. Albany, NY: State University of New York Press, 1988. (International Collection-Miami Classification 247 Do71).
- Elon, Menachem, Jewish Law: History, Sources, Principles. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1994. (International Collection BM520.5.E4313 1994).
- Elon, Menachem, et al. Jewish Law (Mishpat Ivri): Cases and Materials. New York: Matthew Bender 1999. (International Collection KBM 524.J49 1999).
- Weisbard, Phyllis Holman and David Schonberg. Jewish Law: Bibliography of Sources and Scholarship in English. Littleton, CO: Fred B. Rothman & Co. 1989. (Treatise Collection BM520.3.W45 1989).
- Konner, Melvin. Unsettled: An Anthropology of the Jews. Translated by Llewellyn Brown. New York: Viking Compass, 2003.
- Landesman, Dovid. A Practical Guide to Torah Learning. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc., 1995. (Treatise Collection BM503.5.L36 1995).
- Quint, Emanuel. A Restatement of Rabbinic Civil Law. Northvale, NJ: Jason Aronson Inc., 1990. (International Collection KMK1572.Qu5).
- Steinsaltz, Adin. The Talmud, Steinsaltz Edition. New York: Random House New York, 1992.
- Chad Baruch & Karsten Lokken, Research of Jewish Law Issues: A Basic Guide and Bibliography For Students And Practitioners, 77 U. DET. MERCY. L. REV. 303 (2000). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Menachem Elon, The Legal System of Jewish Law, 17 N.Y.U. J. INT'L L. & POL. 221 (1984). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Samuel J. Levine, Teaching Jewish Law in American Law Schools: An Emerging Development in Law and Religion, 26 FORDHAM URB. L.J. 1041 (1999). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Samuel J. Levine, An Introduction to Legislation in Jewish Law, with References to the American Legal System, 29 SETON HALL L. REV. 916 (1999). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Weisbard, Phyllis Holman, Basic Books and Periodicals on Jewish Law: A Guide for Law Librarians, 82 LAW LIBR. J. 519 (1990). (Anglo-American Periodicals).
- Eliezer Segal's official website (accessed January 12, 2005).