| NO. |
PLEADING |
PARTY |
DOCKET DATE |
CTF. OF SERVICE DATE |
| 1. |
United States COMPLAINT
v. SFWMD and Wodraska, Executive Director, SFWMD, DEP, and Dale Twachtman, Secretary, DEP
(Government Exhibits A
& B) |
United States (US)
|
10/11/88 |
|
| 2. |
CIVIL ACTION CERTIFICATION (Civil
Cover Sheet) |
|
10/11/88 |
10/11/88 |
| 3. |
SUMMONS (defendant) - Wodraska
|
Wodraska |
10/27/88 |
|
| 4. |
SUMMONS (to Twachtman, Secretary,
DEP) |
Twachtman |
10/28/88 |
|
| 5. |
SUMMONS (to DEP c/o Twachtman)
|
Twachtman |
10/28/90 |
|
| 6. |
SUMMONS (to Nancy Roen, SFWMD,
General Development Corporation, 111 South Bayshore Drive, Miami) |
|
10/27/88 |
|
| 7. |
SUMMONS (to Nancy Roen, SFWMD, 3301
Gun Club Rd., W. Palm Beach) |
|
10/27/88 |
|
| 8. |
Florida Audubon Society, Florida Wildlife
Federation, Environmental Defense Fund, Inc., Sierra Club, National Wildlife Federation,
Wilderness Society, N ational Parks and Conservation, and Defenders of Wildlife,
Applicants for Intervention. MOTION to intervene as Plaintiffs pursuant to Rules
24(a) and 24(b) |
Florida Audubon Society
(FAS), Florida Wildlife Federation (FWF),Wilderness Society (WS),
National Parks and Conservation
(NPC),Environmental Defense Fund(EDF) |
11/07/88 |
11/07/88 |
| 9. |
U.S. and SFWMD, STIPULATION of
extension of time (extension of date which SFWMD may plead in response to Complaint)
|
US, South Florida Water
Management District (SFWMD) |
1/10/88 |
|
| 10. |
SFWMD MOTION for extension of time
within which to answer or otherwise plead and supporting MEMORANDUM of law |
SFWMD |
11/10/88 |
11/09/88 |
| 11. |
SFWMD APPLICATION OF COUNSEL for
defendant to appear pro haec vice |
SFWMD |
11/14/88 |
11/10/88 |
| 12. |
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition
Inc., MEMORANDUM of law in Support of Motion to Intervene |
Treasure Coast
Environment Coalition (TCEC) |
11/14/88 |
11/11/88 |
| 13. |
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition
Inc., MOTION for leave to intervene as Party Plaintiff |
TCEC |
11/14/88 |
11/10/88 |
| 14. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD extension of
time within which to answer the Complaint) |
|
11/16/88 |
11/16/88 |
| 15. |
SUMMONS to DEP c/o Twachtman)
(Return of Service) |
Twachtman |
11/17/88 |
|
| 16. |
SUMMONS (to DEP c/o Twachtman)
(Return of Service) |
Twachtman |
11/17/88 |
|
| 17. |
ORDER (granting application of
counsel for Defendants, SFWMD to appear pro haec vice) |
|
11/21/88 |
11/18/88 |
| 18. |
SUMMONS (to Nancy Roen, Chairman,
Bd. of Governors SFWMD, General Development Corp., 1111 South Bayshore Drive) (Return of
Service) |
SFWMD |
11/23/88 |
|
| 19. |
SUMMONS (to Wodraska, Exec. Director
SFWMD) (Return of Service) |
SFWMD |
11/23/88 |
|
| 20. |
SUMMONS (to Nancy Roen, Chairman,
Bd. of Governors SFWMD, General Development Corp., 1111 South Bayshore Drive) |
SFWMD |
10/27/88 |
|
| 21. |
SFWMD MOTION for extension of time
in which to respond to Motions of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., and Treasure Coast
Environmental Coalition Inc. to Intervene |
SFWMD |
11/25/88 |
11/23/88 |
| 22. |
Florida Audubon Society, Florida Wildlife
Federation, Environmental Defense Fund Inc., Sierra Club, National Wildlife Federation,
Wilderness Society, National Parks and Conservation, and Defenders of Wildlife, MOTION
to intervene as Plaintiffs pursuant to Rules 24(a) and 24(b) |
FAS,FWF, EDF, Sierra Club
(SC),National Wildlife Federation (NWF),NPC, Defenders of Wildlife (DW) |
11/29/88 |
11/07/88 |
| 23. |
Environmental Defense Fund Inc., et. al., MEMORANDUM
of law in Support of Motion to Intervene as Defendants |
EDF |
11/29/88 |
11/07/88 |
| 24. |
ORDER granting SFWMD extension of
time to respond to Motions of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., and Treasure Coast
Environmental Coalition Inc. to intervene |
|
12/05/88 |
11/30/88 |
| 25. |
DEP, MOTION for extension of time to
Respond to Motions of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., and Treasure Coast Environmental
Coalition Inc. to Intervene |
Florida Department of
Environmental Protection (DEP) |
12/05/88 |
11/30/88 |
| 26. |
SFWMD MOTION for enlargement of the
page limitation for Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motions of Florida Audubon Society,
et. al., and Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. to Intervene |
SFWMD |
12/05/88 |
12/02/88 |
| 27. |
SFWMD, MOTION for extension of time
in Which to Respond to Motion of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., to Intervene as
Plaintiffs |
SFWMD |
12/12/88 |
12/09/88 |
| 28. |
SFWMD, REQUEST for oral argument on
Motion of Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. to Intervene as Plaintiff |
SFWMD |
12/12/88 |
12/09/88 |
| 29. |
SFWMD Motion for Enlargement of Page Limit
and for Rule 19 Joinder |
SFWMD |
12/12/88 |
|
| 30. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM of law in
Opposition to Motion of Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. for Leave to Intervene
|
SFWMD |
12/12/88 |
12/09/88 |
| 31. |
Florida Keys Citizens Coalition Inc., MOTION
to intervene as Plaintiff Pursuant to Rules 24(a) and 24(b) |
Florida Keys Citizens
Coalition (FKCC) |
12/13/88 |
12/05/88 |
| 31.1 |
Florida Keys Citizens Coalition Inc., COMPLAINT-IN-INTERVENTION
|
FKCC |
|
|
| 32. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD enlargement of
page limitation for Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motions of Florida Audubon, et.
al., and Treasure Coast Environmental Coaliti on to Intervene) |
|
12/13/88 |
12/07/88 |
| 33. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD extension of
time in which to Respond to the Motions of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., and Treasure
Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. to interv ene) |
|
12/13/88 |
12/07/88 |
| 34. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD enlargement of
the page limitation for Memorandum in Support of the Motion to Dismiss and the Motion for
Joinder under Rule 19) |
|
12/15/88 |
12/13/88 |
| 35. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD Extension of
time in which to Respond to Motion of Florida Audubon Society to Intervene) |
|
12/15/88 |
12/13/88 |
| 36. |
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition, MOTION
for extension of time in which to Respond to Motion of Florida Audubon Society to
Intervene |
TCEC |
12/15/88 |
12/13/88 |
| 37. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
the Florida Fruit and Vegetable Association, Florida Sugar Cane League Inc., Roth Farms
Inc., KWB Farms, and Beardsley Farms Inc., MOTION to intervene as defenda nts
pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24 |
Western Palm Beach County
Farm Bureau(WPFB), Florida Fruit and Vegetable Association(FFVA), Florida Sugar Cane
League(FSCL),Roth Farms(RF), KWB Farms(KWB) |
12/16/88 |
12/16/88 |
| 38. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., (Agricultural Intervenors, Defendant-Intervenors) ANSWER, DEFENSES,
AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES AND MOTION TO DISMISS |
WPBFB |
12/16/88 |
12/16/88 |
| 39. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., (Agricultural Intervenors, Defendant-Intervenors) MEMORANDUM OF LAW in
Support of Agricultural Intervenors' Motion to Intervene as Defendants Pursuant t o
Federal Rule of Civ. Proc. 24 |
WPFB, FFVA, FSCL, RF, KWB
|
12/16/88 |
12/16/88 |
| 40. |
SFWMD, RESPONSE TO MOTION of Florida
Audubon Society, et. al., to Intervene |
SFWMD |
12/16/88 |
12/15/88 |
| 41. |
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE of Complaint
of Intervener Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. |
TCEC |
12/19/88 |
12/13/88 |
| 42. |
DEP, RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION
of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., and Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. to
Intervene |
DEP |
12/19/88 |
12/12/88 |
| 43. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., (Defendant Agricultural Intervenors), AMENDED CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE LIST for
Motion to Intervene as Defendants |
WPFB, FFVA, RF, FSCL, KWB
|
12/20/88 |
12/16/88 |
| 44. |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
in which to Respond to Motion of Florida Audubon Society, et. al., to Intervene as
Plaintiffs |
SFWMD |
12/20/88 |
12/09/88 |
| 45. |
ORDER (granting SFWMD extension of
time within which to respond to Motions of Florida Keys Citizens Coalition and Western
Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc. to Intervene ) |
|
12/23/88 |
12/22/88 |
| 46. |
U.S., AMENDED COMPLAINT v. SFWMD,
John Wodraska, Exec. Director, DEP, Dale Twachtman, Secretary DEP |
US |
12/23/88 |
|
| 47. |
U.S., NOTICE OF FILING OF CERTIFICATE OF
SERVICE |
US |
12/27/88 |
|
| 48. |
SFWMD, REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT on
their Motion to Dismiss and for Rule 109 Joinder |
SFWMD |
12/27/88 |
12/23/88 |
| 49. |
SFWMD, EXHIBITS TO MOTIONS TO DISMISS
AND FOR JOINDER UNDER RULE 19, or in the Alternative, to Dismiss for Failure to Join
an Indispensable Party |
SFWMD |
12/27/88 |
|
| 50. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support
of Motion of Defendants to Dismiss |
SFWMD |
12/27/88 |
12/23/88 |
| 51. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support
of Motion for Joinder Under Rule 19, or in the alternative to Dismiss for Failure to Join
an indispensable Party |
SFWMD |
12/27/88 |
12/23/88 |
| 52. |
AFFIDAVIT of Dick Slyfield, Director
of Operations Division SFWMD |
|
12/27/88 |
12/19/88 |
| 53. |
U.S., MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME
to Respond to Motion of Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene
and MEMORANDUM OF LAW |
US |
12/29/88 |
12/29/88 |
| 54. |
ORDER (granting extension of time to
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition to file its reply brief) |
|
01/03/89 |
12/20/88 |
| 55. |
U.S., NOTICE OF INTENT and or MOTION
FOR EXPANSION OF TIME |
US |
01/06/88 |
01/06/88 |
| 56. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support
of Renewed Motion to dismiss |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
03/06/89 |
| 57. |
SFWMD, FURTHER OPPOSITION TO MOTION
of Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene (Attachments Exhibits
A & B) |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
03/06/89 |
| 58. |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME
to Respond to Motions of Florida Keys Citizen Coalition and Western Palm Beach County Farm
Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
12/19/88 |
| 59. |
SFWMD, REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT on
their Motion to Stay Discovery and Opposition to Motion to Intervene of Western Palm Beach
County Farm Bureau Inc. |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
01/06/89 |
| 60. |
SFWMD, MOTION TO STAY DISCOVERY and
to Exempt this Action from Local Rule 14 Pending Disposition of their Motion to Dismiss
|
SFWMD |
12/09/89 |
01/06/89 |
| 60.1 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting Motion to
stay discovery) |
|
|
|
| 60.2 |
SFWMD, REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT on
their Motion to Stay Discovery and Opposition to Motion to Intervene of Western Palm Beach
County Farm Bureau Inc., et. al., |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 60.3 |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF THE
PAGE LIMITATION for Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion of Western Palm Beach
County Farm Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 60.4 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting extension
of time) |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 60.5 |
MOTION of SFWMD FOR EXTENSION OF
TIME in which to respond to Motion of Florida Keys Citizens Coalition to Intervene as
Plaintiff |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 60.6 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting extension
of time) |
|
|
|
| 61. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support
of Motion of Defendants to Stay Discovery and to Except this Action from Local Rule 14
Pending Disposition of their Motion to Dismiss |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
01/06/89 |
| 62. |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF THE
PAGE LIMITATION for Memorandum of Law in Opposition to Motion of Western Palm Beach
County Farm Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene |
SFWMD |
01/09/89 |
01/06/89 |
| 63. |
U.S., NOTICE of Filing Joint Report
of Scheduling (and Exhibits) |
US |
|
|
| 63.1 |
JOINT REPORT of Scheduling Meeting
|
|
|
|
| 63.2 |
PROPOSED Scheduling Meeting |
|
|
|
| 64. |
MOTION TO MAKE SPECIAL LIMITED
APPEARANCE as Co-Counsel for Florida Keys Citizens Coalition Inc. by Thomas Reese,
Esq. |
FKCC |
01/10/89 |
01/03/89 |
| 64.1 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting
Appearances) |
|
|
|
| 65. |
SFWMD, RESPONSE TO MOTION of Florida
Keys Citizens Coalitions Inc. to Intervene |
SFWMD |
01/11/89 |
01/10/89 |
| 65.1 |
STIPULATION Regarding Intervention
|
|
01/09/89 |
|
| 65.2 |
STIPULATION Regarding Intervention
|
|
12/15/88 |
|
| 66. |
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition, MOTION
FOR EXTENSION OF TIME |
TCEC |
01/13/89 |
|
| 66.1 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting extension
of time) |
|
|
|
| 67. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., (Agricultural Intervenors) UNOPPOSED MOTION AND MEMORANDUM FOR LEAVE TO FILE
CONSOLIDATED REPLY to all parties, Memoranda in Opposition to Agricultural
Intervenors' Motion to Intervene |
WPFB,RF,KWB,United States
Sugar Corporation (USSC) |
01/13/89 |
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| 68. |
DEP, MOTION TO DISMISS AMENDED COMPLAINT
|
DEP |
01/20/89 |
01/19/89 |
| 69. |
DEP, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support of
Motion to Dismiss Amended Complaint |
DEP |
01/20/89 |
01/18/89 |
| 70. |
JOINDER OF DEFENDANTS, DEP and Dale
Twachtman in Responses of Defendants SFWMD to Motions to Intervene |
DEP, Twachtman |
01/20/89 |
01/19/89 |
| 71. |
ORDER (granting extension of time to
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition to file reply brief to Memorandum in Opposition)
|
|
01/20/89 |
01/18/89 |
| 72. |
ORDER (granting enlargement of page
limitation of Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Western Palm Beach Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., to Intervene) |
|
01/20/89 |
01/18/89 |
| 73. |
ORDER (granting enlargement of the
page limitation for Memorandum in Opposition to Motion of Western Palm Beach County Farm
Bureau Inc., et. al., to Intervene)(duplicate of #72) |
|
01/20/89 |
01/18/89 |
| 74. |
SFWMD, RENEWED MOTION to Dismiss
|
SFWMD |
01/19/89 |
01/20/89 |
| 75. |
U.S., MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME
to Respond to Defendants SFWMD 's Motion to Stay Discovery and to Exempt this action from
Local Rule 14 |
US |
01/20/89 |
01/20/89 |
| 76. |
U.S., MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME
to file Joint Response to all defendants' Motions to Dismiss and a Joint Response to
Motions for Rule 19 Joinder |
US |
01/23/89 |
01/23/89 |
| 77. |
U.S., NOTICE of filing transcript of
telephone conference of December 22, 1988 |
US |
01/23/89 |
01/23/89 |
| 78. |
TRANSCRIPT of tele-conference
|
|
01/23/89 |
01/22/88 |
| 79. |
ORDER (granting U.S. Motion for
enlargement of time to respond to Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc. Motion to
Intervene) |
|
01/24/89 |
01/05/89 |
| 80. |
ORDER of Reference (all discovery
matters referred to Honorable Samuel Smargon U.S. Magistrate) |
|
01/24/89 |
01/20/89 |
| 81. |
ORDER (granting Motion of Florida
Keys Citizens Coalition to intervene as Plaintiff) |
|
01/24/89 |
01/20/89 |
| 82. |
SFWMD, Treasure Coast Environmental
Coalition Inc., STIPULATION Regarding Intervention (Exhibit: Stipulation Regarding
Intervention Florida Audubon Society, et. al.,) |
SFWMD, TCEC |
01/26/89 |
01/24/89 |
| |
|
|
|
|
| 83. |
Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc.
FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT of Intervenor |
TCEC |
01/26/89 |
01/24/89 |
| 83.1 |
AFFIDAVIT of Joseph Filonowicz,
President of Treasure Coast Environmental Coalition Inc. |
TCEC |
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
| 84. |
U.S., MOTION FOR EXPANSION OF PAGE LIMIT
for Opposition to Motion to Intervene |
US |
01/30/89 |
01/30/89 |
| 85. |
SFWMD, MEMORANDUM OF LAW in Support
of Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 11 |
SFWMD |
02/02/89 |
02/01/89 |
| 86. |
SFWMD, EXHIBITS in Support of Motion
for Sanctions Under Rule 11 |
SFWMD |
02/02/89 |
|
| 87. |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR SANCTIONS under
Rule 11 |
SFWMD |
02/02/89 |
02/01/89 |
| 87.1 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting sanctions)
|
|
|
|
| 87.2 |
REQUEST by defendants SFWMD FOR
ORAL ARGUMENT on their Motion for Sanctions under Rule 11 |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 87.3 |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF THE
PAGE LIMITATION for Memorandum of Law in Support of Motions for Sanctions Under Rule
11 |
SFWMD |
|
|
| 87.4 |
PROPOSED ORDER (granting enlargement
of page limitation) |
|
|
|
| 88. |
SFWMD, REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
|
SFWMD |
02/02/89 |
02/01/89 |
| 89. |
SFWMD, MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF THE
PAGE LIMITATION For Memorandum of Law in Support of Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 11
|
SFWMD |
02/03/89 |
02/01/89 |
| 90. |
Florida Keys Citizen Coalition Inc., FIRST
AMENDED COMPLAINT |
FKCC |
03/03/89 |
|
| 91. |
NOTICE OF ORAL ARGUMENT on Motion to
Stay Discovery |
|
02/07/89 |
02/07/89 |
| 92. |
ORDER (granting U.S. Motion for
enlargement of time to respond to SFWMD Motion to Stay Discovery and Rescheduling Oral
Arguments) |
|
02/09/89 |
02/09/89 |
| 93. |
SFWMD, NOTICE of Appearance of
Counsel |
SFWMD |
02/13/89 |
02/10/89 |
| 94. |
NOTICE OF ORAL ARGUMENT on Motion to
Stay Discovery |
|
02/14/89 |
02/07/89 |
| 95. |
Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc.,
et. al., (Agricultural Intervenors) CONSOLIDATED REPLY to all Parties' Memoranda In
Opposition to the Motion of Western Palm Beach County Farm Bureau Inc., et. a l., to
Intervene |
WPFB, RF, KWB, USSC |
02/14/89 |
02/10/89 |
| 95.1 |
APPENDIX A Florida Fruit and
Vegetable Association APPENDIX B Western
Palm Beach County Farm Bureau
APPENDIX C Florida Sugar Cane League |
|
|
|
| 96. |
NOTICE of Amended Certificate of
Service |
|
02/15/89 |
02/13/89 |
| 97. |
U.S., MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME
to Respond to SFWMD 's Motion for Sanctions Under Rule 11 and Incorporated MEMORANDUM
|
US |
02/15/89 |
|
| 98. |
U.S., MOTION TO FILE SUPPLEMENTAL
MEMORANDUM In Support of Opposition to Motion to Intervene |
US |
02/16/89 |
02/16/89 |
| 98.1 |
U.S., SUPPLEMENTAL MEMORANDUM In
Support of Opposition to Motion to Intervene with attachment ORDER (Mangsota-88,
Inc. v. Greer G. Tidwell Regional Administration for Region IV; Lee Thomas, Administ rator
U.S. CPA) |
US |
|
02/16/89 |
| 99. |
NOTICE of Voluntary Dismissal
Without Prejudice of the Florida Keys Coalition Claim for Attorney's Fees |
|
02/17/89 |
02/14/89 |
| 100. |
JOINDER OF DEP and DALE TWACHTMAN IN
MOTION OF SFWMD TO STAY DISCOVERY and to Exempt this Action From
Local Rule 14 Pending Disposition of Their Mot ion to Dismiss |
DEP, Twachtman |
02/21/89 |
|
